This page is for founders, freelance SEOs and agency owners who ran HubSpot's AI Search Grader and want to know what else exists, free or paid. HubSpot's grader is free, needs no account, and reports what ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini say about your brand once. It does not track anything over time. Below I compare it with 6 alternatives on the same 5 criteria.
Disclosure: I make AEO Copilot, and 2 of the options below (the free checker and the $9 Startup plan) are mine. I use AEO Copilot daily. I have used HubSpot's grader, Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit, Peec.ai and Profound hands-on, as I describe in my 14-tool roundup. HubSpot's paid AEO tier I compare from its public pricing only. Every competitor price was checked on the vendor's own pricing page on 29 September 2026.
Short answer: for a free, no-signup check of whether ChatGPT names your brand on a real buyer question, use HubSpot's grader or AEO Copilot's free checker. For tracking over time, the cheapest option here is AEO Copilot's Startup plan at $9/month for 4 engines; HubSpot charges $50/month for 25 prompts, Semrush $99/month, and Peec.ai $95/month.
A grader predicts, a live prompt measures
A rubric-based grader scores your site against a fixed list: schema markup, content structure, crawlability. The number predicts AI-readiness. It does not tell you what ChatGPT says when a buyer asks about your category, because that answer also depends on who mentions you across the web and how the model reads the question.
A live check sends a real prompt to a real model and reports whether your brand is in the answer. HubSpot's grader and AEO Copilot's checker both work this way. The difference is what comes with it: HubSpot adds a visibility score, sentiment and share of voice; AEO Copilot adds 6 technical checks on your site.
7 AEO grader alternatives on the same 5 criteria
I compare every option on the same 5 criteria, in 1 table: what it checks, which engines it asks, whether it runs once or on a schedule, what it costs, and whether you need an account.
Competitor prices checked on each vendor's pricing page on 29 September 2026. Monthly billing.
| Tool | What it checks | Engines | Once or tracked | Cost | Account needed |
| HubSpot AI Search Grader | Visibility score, sentiment, share of voice | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini | Once | Free | No |
| AEO Copilot free checker | Live answer to your buyer prompt, plus 6 technical checks | ChatGPT | Once | Free | No |
| HubSpot AEO (paid) | Ongoing monitoring inside HubSpot | Not checked for this page | Tracked | $50/mo, 25 prompts, free trial | Yes |
| AEO Copilot Startup | Mentions, sentiment, competitors, citations | Any 4 of ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews | Tracked weekly | $9/mo, 50 prompts | Yes |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | AI visibility next to Semrush SEO data | ChatGPT, Google AI Mode | Tracked | $99/mo, 25 prompts, +$99 per extra domain | Yes |
| Peec.ai | Mentions, sentiment, competitors, sources | 3 of your choice, more as add-ons | Tracked daily | $95/mo, 50 prompts | Yes |
| Profound | Monitoring plus AI content briefs | 3 on trial, up to 9 on Enterprise | Tracked daily | 7-day trial, then custom Enterprise | Yes |
The 2 free options: HubSpot's grader and AEO Copilot's checker
HubSpot AI Search Grader. I've run it hands-on. Enter a brand and you get a one-time snapshot across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, with a visibility score, sentiment and share of voice against competitors. No account and no caps. It does not check whether your site is technically readable, and it runs once, so there is no trend. Pick it if you want a quick read across 3 engines and a score to share.
AEO Copilot free checker. It asks ChatGPT the buyer prompt you type, shows you the full answer and the competitors it named instead of you, then runs 6 technical checks: page access, indexability (robots.txt and noindex), schema markup, page title, meta description, and whether key information sits in the first 150 words. No signup and no credit card; the email field is optional. It asks 1 engine only. Pick it if you want to see the exact answer for a question your buyers ask, and the fixes on your own site.
The paid trackers: from $9 to Enterprise
A one-time grade can't tell you whether last month's work moved anything. For that the prompts have to run on a schedule.
- AEO Copilot, Startup plan ($9/month). 1 brand, 50 prompts, any 4 of 5 engines, weekly runs, API and MCP. The same live-prompt method as the free checker, on a schedule. It runs weekly, not daily, and covers 4 engines at a time. Pick it if you are a startup or freelancer who wants a trend line on a small budget.
- HubSpot AEO ($50/month). 25 prompts, free trial, inside the HubSpot CRM. Pick it if your team already works in HubSpot and wants AI data next to its contacts. Outside HubSpot, $50 for 25 prompts is thin.
- Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit ($99/month). I've used it hands-on: 25 prompts across ChatGPT and Google AI Mode, $99 for each extra domain. Pick it if your team already pays for Semrush and wants 1 login.
- Peec.ai ($95/month). 50 prompts on 3 models, daily runs, unlimited seats, extra models from $35 each. Pick it if you run in-house marketing at a mid-market company and want daily data.
- Profound (Enterprise). Up to 9 engines, content briefs, SOC 2. Pick it if you are a large brand with a GEO team and a compliance review to pass.
The full breakdown of the last 3, including what you really pay once every engine is switched on, is in Profound vs Peec.ai vs AEO Copilot, with the dated pricing table for 14 tools.
Comparing HubSpot's paid tracker rather than the free grader? See HubSpot AEO alternatives.
FAQ: AEO graders and checkers
Is there a free AEO grader tool?
There are 2 I'd use. HubSpot's AI Search Grader gives a one-time score across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini. AEO Copilot's free checker shows the live ChatGPT answer to your buyer prompt and adds 6 technical checks. Neither needs an account.
What's the difference between an AEO grader and an AEO checker?
A rubric-based grader scores a page against a fixed technical list (schema, structure, crawlability). A checker like AEO Copilot's sends a real prompt to a real model and reports whether your brand appears in the answer. The rubric predicts readiness; the live check records what the model said.
What is the best HubSpot AI Search Grader alternative?
For free: AEO Copilot's checker, which shows the full ChatGPT answer and checks page access, indexability, schema, title, meta description and whether key information sits in the first 150 words. For tracking over time: AEO Copilot's Startup plan at $9/month with 4 engines, or HubSpot's own paid tier at $50/month if you already use HubSpot.
Does an AEO score predict actual AI mentions?
Only partly. A technical score tells you whether models can parse and quote a page. Whether they name your brand also depends on mentions elsewhere on the web. Fix the technical gaps a grader finds, then confirm with a live prompt check.
Want the answer ChatGPT gives your buyers today? Run the free AEO checker on your brand.